Harvest Profit alternative: GrainPosition and Harvest Profit, compared honestly

Both keep a grain book: contracts, bins, loads and settlements. Harvest Profit is farm finance software built around profit field by field, with the grain book inside it. GrainPosition starts from the grain book, checks each settlement against its contract, and now adds fields, field work and profit by field around it. Here is what each does, what each costs, and who owns them, including where Harvest Profit is the better choice.

Written by the person building GrainPosition, so read it knowing that. Harvest Profit's details checked against its own pages on 3 October 2026 (the price chart, weather and deadline rows on 18 October 2026); sources at the bottom.

Side by side

 GrainPositionHarvest Profit
Contracts: cash, forward, basis, hedge-to-arriveFixed, basis, futures only (HTA), price later, averaging and minimum price. One leg set shows as half priced; with both, the flat price is worked out from the futures and basis you type. Pricing deadlines in Coming upYes. Basis contracts update from live CBOT futures
Bins, loads and what is still owed on each contractYesYes
Scale tickets from a photoYes, and contracts and settlements too, from a photo or PDFYes, scale tickets, in its driver app
Each settlement checked line by lineYes: grade, weight and dockage, freight and each deduction, explained or flagged, with the Canadian Grain Commission's deadline for farms in Western Canada; also drying shrink against moisture, each truck's empty weight against its usual, and the grade against your Harvest Sample resultsTracks settlements; a line-by-line check isn't described on its features page
Log loads with no phone signalPlannedYes, in the driver app
Profit and loss, field by fieldYes: by farm, crop and field, from what each crop sold for, its costs, and the farm’s own costs and income (fuel, repairs, depreciation, crop insurance and the like) shared by acres; crop years side by side. No profit mapsYes, with profit maps from John Deere Operations Center
Live futures pricesNo. Unsold grain is valued at the bid you type inCorn, soybeans and three US wheats, in the US and Canada. No canola feed listed
Marketing plan with price alertsNot yetYes
Your sales on a price chartYes: each sale drawn on your province's price since 2016, with your break-evenYour marketing targets on futures charts; your own sales on one not stated
Weather near the farm, beside your contractsYes: the season's rain, heat, frost and drought at the nearest station against its own average, with what's left on each crop if the yield comes in short (Canada)Not stated
Deadlines and a weekly emailYes: delivery windows, price-by dates, the grade window and when payment protection ends in Coming up, and a Monday emailPrice and date target alerts; deadline reminders and a summary email not stated
Equipment costs, crop insurance grid, scenarios, landlord shares, several entitiesPartly: the machines with their hours, service due and repair costs, which go into the profit and loss. No crop insurance grid, scenarios, landlord shares or several entitiesYes
Connects to other farm softwareNot yet. Exports everything as CSVJohn Deere Operations Center and Agrimatics Libra CART grain cart scales
PhoneNot in the app stores; built for a phone's browser, and installs on the home screen from itApps for iPhone and Android
Price$249 a year (or $25 a month) for farms that join in early access, $349 after; CAD in Canada, USD in the US. Free during early access$1,600 USD a year. Optional setup help, $5,000 USD
TrialFree during early access, and a sample farm with no account14 days, and a 30-day money-back guarantee
Owned byIndependent, built in WinnipegJohn Deere, since 2020. Canadian farms sign with John Deere Canada

Choose Harvest Profit if

You want to run the business side of the farm in one place: profit and loss by field and below it, equipment costs, crop insurance scenarios, landlord shares and several entities. You already use John Deere Operations Center or a Libra CART grain cart scale and want that data to flow in. You grow mainly corn, soybeans or US wheat and want revenue to move with live futures. Or your harvest crew needs a driver app that logs loads with no signal. Those are real strengths, and GrainPosition doesn't have them.

Look at GrainPosition if

You want the grain book done properly, with the farm around it rather than a finance system: every contract, bin and load, how much is sold and at what average, and whether each settlement paid what the contract said, set up in an evening. You grow canola, peas, lentils or other crops without a futures feed in Harvest Profit, and want to value them at your own bids. You want contracts and settlements read from a photo as well as tickets. You'd like your fields, field work, scouting notes and profit by field kept next to it, without John Deere Operations Center. Or you'd rather pay a few hundred Canadian dollars than $1,600 US.

On who owns it, here are just the facts: Harvest Profit has been part of John Deere since 2020. In Canada its contracting company is John Deere Canada ULC, and its terms say the company, its affiliates and related entities may use data about the service, including customer data and data derived from it, as set out in its privacy notice. Whether that matters is your call. GrainPosition's position is written on its front page: your prices are not aggregated, sold or shared, and there is no second business model.

Moving over from Harvest Profit or another app

If you can export your contracts to a spreadsheet or CSV, import that file into GrainPosition and the columns are matched for you; you check every row before anything is saved. Or send me the export and I’ll set up your book for you. I haven’t tested Harvest Profit’s export, so if it doesn’t come across cleanly, that’s on me to fix, not on you to retype.

Other options worth knowing

Combyne, owned by Bayer, is the closest to GrainPosition in scope, with an app from the app store and connections to FieldView (GrainPosition and Combyne compared). Traction is farm accounting software whose top tier adds grain contracts and settlement matching. And a well-kept spreadsheet is still a reasonable answer for a small book: there is a free one.

All of them side by side, with Bushel Farm and GrainFox too: grain marketing software compared.

See it before deciding anything

The real app on a made-up Manitoba farm: every tab and form, with no account. Nothing you enter there is saved.

Open the sample farm

Sources

Harvest Profit, John Deere, Operations Center, Libra CART, Combyne and Traction are names and trademarks of their respective owners. GrainPosition is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them. Where this page says something isn't described, that means it couldn't be confirmed from the product's own public pages.

Spotted something out of date or wrong about Harvest Profit? Email hello@grainposition.com and it gets corrected.

Check a grain settlement from a photo

Upload a photo or PDF to see the settlement's figures explained and checked. Add the contract to compare its price, grade and freight.

Check a settlement photo

Free, no account. Review the extracted figures before checking. Documents are processed by Anthropic and are not stored. Privacy