Compared honestly · checked 18 October 2026
Grain marketing software, compared.
Most grain farms don’t use any of these apps. They use a spreadsheet, a notebook, or each elevator’s own website. So this comparison starts there, and then puts six apps side by side, GrainPosition included.
Written by the person building GrainPosition, so read it knowing that. Every claim about another product comes from its own website, linked under each one. Where something couldn’t be confirmed there, the table says “not stated” rather than guess.
Which one fits
The short version, before the table. Each card jumps to the details.
Side by side
| GrainPositionIndependent, Winnipeg | Your spreadsheetor a notebook | Each buyer’s websitemyBunge, Richardson, CargillAg | CombyneBayer | Bushel FarmIndependent, Fargo ND | Harvest ProfitJohn Deere | GrainFoxFarmLink, Winnipeg | TractionIndependent, Indiana | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sold and left to sellper crop, across every buyer | YesContracted, priced and unsold against expected production, for each crop | If you build itRight until a row is missed | One buyerYour contracts with that buyer only, never the total | YesContracted and left to sell, updated as contracts go in | Yes% marketed and % unprotected per crop | PartlySold and unsold bushels in the profit and loss; bushels still owed on contracts | PartlyTracks sales, deliveries and inventory; the breakdown isn’t described | Top tierGrain positions on the Enterprise tier, priced on request |
| Your real average priceweighted by tonnes or bushels | YesWeighted per crop; open contracts stay out of it | If the formula’s rightA dragged formula breaks it quietly | NoNot across buyers | YesAverage, lowest and highest contract price per crop | YesWeighted average of final-priced bushels | MixedIts average cash price blends sold and unsold bushels | Not stated | Not stated |
| Break-evenper crop, from your costs | YesEach crop’s plan and per-acre costs give a break-even per tonne or bushel, set against every sale | If you build it | PartlymyBunge works out return per acre; no break-even price stated | YesFrom an average cost of production per acre | YesCost of production and break-even on the $599 plan | YesFrom budgets and costs | YesBreak-even scenarios on the $3,000 plan | YesPer bushel and per acre, from the books |
| Your sales on the price chartagainst the market, over the years | YesEach of your sales drawn on your province’s price since 2016, with your break-even | If you build it | No | Not statedCharts show your sold position, not your sales against a price | Not stated | Not statedYour targets on futures charts | Not statedFutures and risk charts | Not stated |
| Settlement checkedagainst its contract and scale tickets | YesSplit into price, weight and each deduction; each line explained or flagged (a grade below the contract or below your Grain Commission Harvest Sample, a charge not on it, freight off its rate, shrink beyond what drying removes, a truck's empty weight above its usual); and checked that the statement adds up | By hand | Shows themThe checking is up to you | PartlySettled price against contract price, and total discounts | NoSettlements are in each buyer’s Bushel portal | PartlyTickets matched to contracts, settled and unsettled loads | Not stated | Top tier“Settlement matching” on the Enterprise tier |
| An offer, before you take itwhat it does to your book | YesFrom a screenshot or the pasted text: how sold it makes you, the new average, what’s due that month | Copy the sheet | No | Not stated | NoShows potential profit on unsold grain instead | ScenariosYield × price what-if grids for the season | ScenariosSell now or hold, against market scenarios | Not stated |
| Getting contracts inwithout typing them | YesA photo or PDF of contracts, tickets and settlements, or your Excel or CSV file. Queue document photos offline, then read and review them online. | Typing | Already thereThe buyer enters them | YesPhoto, screenshot or PDF; buyers can email documents in | US onlyAutomatic from Bushel-network buyers, for contracts in US dollars only | TicketsScale ticket photos from the driver app; grain cart scales | Other appsLinks with AgExpert, Farm at Hand and John Deere | Not stated |
| Bins on the farmwhat’s in each one | YesCapacity, crop, yard, movements and counts | If you build it | NoOnly grain stored with that buyer | YesBy yard, plus bags and elevator storage | YesOn the $599 plan | YesBins, loads and landlord shares | PartlyBins in the farm profile; detail not described | YesCrop and bin inventory on Plus and Pro |
| Weather near the farmand what a short crop would do | YesThe season’s rain, heat, frost and drought at the nearest station, against its own average, beside what each crop has contracted and what’s left if the yield comes in short (Canada) | No | Not stated | Not stated | PartlyRainfall per field with email alerts, US fields only; not tied to contracts | Not stated | PartlyWeather answers from its AI assistant, an add-on; not tied to contracts | Not stated |
| Deadlines and a weekly emailso nothing slips | YesComing up: delivery windows, price-by dates, the 7-day grade window, when payment protection ends, production reports, bin checks; a Monday email with what’s due in two weeks and where your grain stands | If you build it | PartlymyBunge alerts on deliveries and bookings; CargillAg on scale tickets; no due-date reminders stated | PartlyA monthly view of deliveries; scheduled reports only through an advisor’s Copilot | Not statedPrice alerts | Not statedPrice and date target alerts | Not statedPrice alerts | Not stated |
| Family, employees and your accountanteach with their own access | YesInvite by email as owner, family, employee (tickets, bins and harvest, with no prices, settlements or costs), read only, or marketing advisor (contracts and the plan; a Clients screen across their farms) | Share the fileEveryone sees everything | One login eachPer buyer | Not stated | YesShare the account with as many people as you need; roles not stated | PartlyA driver app with permissions that keep financial data private; reports shared as downloads | YesUnlimited account members, even on the free plan; roles not stated | YesAccount sharing on every plan, accountant included; permission levels not stated |
| Tells you when to sell | No, by designIt shows what a sale would do; the decision stays yours | No | NoShows that buyer’s bids | NoA separate product lets your own advisor work with you | No | NoAlerts when your own target prices hit | YesAI sell or hold signals, expert reports, a human advisor on the top plan | No |
| Canadian farmsdollars, tonnes, buyers | YesCAD or USD, tonnes or bushels at each crop’s own weight | Yes | Yes | YesCanada and the US, charged in CAD or USD | Limited“Only supports USD at this time” | LimitedAvailable in Canada, priced in USD; no canola futures feed listed | YesCanadian, with Canadian market reports | US-focusedUS tax forms; Canada not stated on its site |
| On a phone | BrowserBuilt for a phone’s browser; installs on the home screen, not from an app store | Pinch and zoom | AppsOne per buyer | AppiPhone and Android | AppiPhone and Android | AppiPhone and Android, plus a driver app | AppiPhone and Android | AppiPhone and Android |
| Price a yearas listed on each site | Free in early access, then $249 a year (or $25 a month) for founding farms, $349 at launch, in CAD or USD | Free, plus your evenings | Free | $499.99, or $49.99 a month, CAD or USD | $199 for contracts, $599 with marketing and bins; currency not stated | $1,600 USD | Free basic plan; $1,500 or $3,000 CAD; top plan per acre | $950 to $3,950; grain contracts on Enterprise, priced on request |
| Free trial | Free during early access; a sample farm and spreadsheet with no account | — | — | 30 days | 30 days | 14 days | 14 days on paid plans | Up to 30 days on some plans |
Tap a name above to add it to the table, or take it away. With more than two on a phone, swipe sideways.
Each one, in a paragraph
GrainPosition
Independent, built in Winnipeg · free in early access, then $249 a year, or $25 a month, for founding farms (CAD or USD)
Good at: the grain book first, and the farm around it. What’s in each bin, every contract, the loads hauled and each settlement split into where the money went, each line explained or flagged for checking, with the deadline to ask the Canadian Grain Commission for a binding grade (farms in Western Canada) and a message ready for the buyer. A photo of a contract, ticket or settlement fills the form in, and a buyer's offer can be checked against the book before you answer. A device-only queue holds document captures offline for reading and review after reconnection; farm records are not edited offline. Each crop’s break-even comes from its plan, your sales are drawn on your province’s price over the years, the season’s rain and drought at your nearest station sit beside what you’ve contracted, and the deadlines that cost money if missed come up on the dashboard and in a Monday email. Around it: each quarter from the satellites with its crops year by year, the field work done on it (spray passes with the tank mix, weather and each label’s pre-harvest interval) and scouting notes; jobs for the people on the farm; the seed, fertilizer and chemical in the shed; a profit and loss by farm, crop and field, with the farm’s own costs (fuel, repairs, labour, depreciation and the like) shared by acres; crop years side by side; and the machines with their hours and service due.
Worth knowing: your prices are not aggregated, sold or shared, and there is no second business model. It doesn’t tell you when to sell, isn’t accounting software, and doesn’t connect to QuickBooks or John Deere yet.
A spreadsheet, or a notebook
Free · already yours
Good at: exactly what you built it for. For a few contracts with one or two buyers, it’s a perfectly good answer, and there’s a free grain contract spreadsheet here with the weighted average done right.
Worth knowing: it’s only as right as its last formula, nobody checks settlements in it, and it’s hard work on a phone in the truck.
Each buyer’s website
Free · myBunge (formerly myViterra), Richardson Pioneer, CargillAg and others
Good at: your contracts, scale tickets and settlements with that one buyer, entered by the buyer, often within minutes of the truck crossing the scale.
Worth knowing: each one only shows its own grain. Sell to three buyers and you have three logins and no total: no average across them, no bins, and nobody checking their settlement but you.
Sources: myBunge, Richardson Pioneer, CargillAg
Combyne
Bayer CropScience, since the end of 2022 · $499.99 a year or $49.99 a month · 30-day trial
Good at: a mature, Canadian-built grain marketing app. Contracts, tickets and settlements read from a photo or PDF, or emailed in by your buyer. Bins by yard, grain bags and elevator storage. Crop years side by side, and a separate product so your marketing advisor can work in it with you.
Worth knowing: its data policy says “Combyne does not sell your data” and that you own what you put in. It describes itself as a division of Bayer CropScience Inc. Settlements are compared on price and total discounts rather than split deduction by deduction.
Sources: features, pricing, data use, data use policy. More in GrainPosition and Combyne, compared.
Bushel Farm
Bushel Inc., independent, Fargo, North Dakota · $199 or $599 a year · 30 days free
Good at: contracts that arrive by themselves. If your elevators run on Bushel, more than 3,500 locations in the US and Canada, contracts flow in from their own systems with nothing to type. It also tracks hedges, futures and options against your position.
Worth knowing: its help centre says it “only supports USD at this time”, so contracts in Canadian dollars don’t come in automatically. It says it doesn’t sell your data, and keeps the right to use anonymized data.
Sources: pricing, contracts in CAD, marketing overview, privacy notice
Harvest Profit
John Deere, since 2020 · $1,600 USD a year · 14-day trial
Good at: profit, field by field, live against CBOT futures, tied to John Deere Operations Center. A driver app for loads and ticket photos that works offline, grain cart scales, landlord shares and several entities. It’s farm finance software with a grain book inside, more than a grain book.
Worth knowing: it’s priced in US dollars, and its futures feeds cover corn, soybeans and US wheats, with no canola listed. In Canada you sign with John Deere Canada, and its terms let the company and its affiliates use customer data and data derived from it.
Sources: features, pricing, terms of service, Canada. In more detail: GrainPosition and Harvest Profit compared.
GrainFox
FarmLink Marketing Solutions, Winnipeg · free basic plan, $1,500 or $3,000 CAD a year · 14-day trial
Good at: telling you what the market is doing and what to do about it. Twenty years of Canadian grain market analysis, expert reports, AI sell or hold signals and, on the top plan, a human advisor. Links with AgExpert and Farm at Hand, which many Canadian farms already use.
Worth knowing: it’s an advice service first and a record book second. It says “your data stays yours”; its privacy policy lets it use aggregated data that no longer identifies your farm.
Sources: plans, AgExpert, privacy policy, FarmLink, 20 years
Traction
Traction Ag, independent, owned by farm investors, Indiana · $950 to $3,950 a year · grain contracts on Enterprise
Good at: the books. Farm accounting, payroll, several entities, land agreements and profit per field and per bushel. It bought Granular Business and Conservis; its Enterprise tier, for large operations, adds grain contracts, positions and settlement matching.
Worth knowing: it’s built around US tax forms, and the grain contract tier is priced on request. By default it anonymizes and aggregates farm data for benchmarking, and you can turn that off.
Sources: pricing, advanced farm management, about, trust center
Where GrainPosition falls short
Fair is fair. Today, GrainPosition:
- is new, in free early access, with no track record yet
- has no app in the app stores; it runs in your phone’s browser and installs on the home screen from there
- doesn’t connect to other farm software or to buyers’ systems; it exports everything as CSV, plus a calendar year’s sales, deductions and costs for the accountant
- doesn’t import futures and options from a broker; they’re typed into a trade log beside the contracts (basis and futures-only contracts are tracked too, with their pricing deadlines)
- doesn’t tell you when to sell, and won’t
See it on a sample farm first
The real app on a made-up Manitoba farm: every tab and form, with no account. Nothing you enter there is saved.
Open the sample farm Watch the one-minute videoCheck a grain settlement from a photo
Upload a photo or PDF to see the settlement's figures explained and checked. Add the contract to compare its price, grade and freight.
Check a settlement photoFree, no account. Review the extracted figures before checking. Documents are processed by Anthropic and are not stored. Privacy
About this page
Each product was checked against its own website on 1 October 2026 (the row on family, employees and your accountant on 10 October 2026; break-even, sales on the price chart, weather, and deadlines and a weekly email on 18 October 2026): pricing, feature and help pages, data policies and app store listings, linked under each one. Prices are as listed, before tax. Products change, so check with each company before you decide.
Combyne, Bushel Farm, Harvest Profit, GrainFox, Traction, myBunge, Richardson Pioneer and CargillAg are names and trademarks of their owners. GrainPosition is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them.
Spotted something out of date or wrong? Email hello@grainposition.com and it gets corrected.